VIDEO: Officers On Leave After Using 'Coin-Toss' To Make Arrest Decision


Two Roswell officers used a coin toss phone app to determine whether a reckless driver would go to jail or be released.

Roswell, GA – Two Roswell police officers have been placed on leave after bodycam footage showed them using a coin-toss phone app to decide whether or not to arrest a woman for reckless driving (video below).

The incident occurred in on April 7, when Roswell Officer Courtney Brown spotted a vehicle traveling approximately 85 miles per hour in a 45 mile per hour zone, NBC News reported.

Officer brown initiated a traffic stop on the black 2005 Mercury Sable, which was being driven by 24-year-old Sarah Webb, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported.

“You know how fast you were just going, ma’am?” Officer Brown asked Webb as she stood inside the woman’s open driver’s door, bodycam footage showed.

“I’m so sorry, I’m late for work,” Webb said, rifling through her purse.

“So you can go over 80 miles per hour?...No, ma’am,” Officer Brown told her.

She then requested Webb’s driver and vehicle information and told the woman to shut off her vehicle and pass her the keys.

“The ground’s wet, it’s been raining, you’re going over 80 miles an hour on this type of a road – that’s reckless driving, ma’am,” Officer Brown pointed out.

Officer Brown returned to her patrol vehicle to run Webb’s information.

“I’m gonna take her probably for reckless,” Officer Brown told Officer Kristee Wilson when she arrived at the traffic stop. “She flew past me going probably 80-85…I had to get up to 90 to catch her. What do you think?”

She noted that she didn’t have any speed detection to verify Webb’s rate of travel, but Officer Wilson pointed out that Officer Brown’s camera would show the speed her car was going as Webb passed her.

The two officers discussed the wet roadway and the risk Webb posed to herself and others.

“I mean, that’s unacceptable,” Officer Brown said, adding that she told Webb she should have called her boss to say she would be late. “Do not [speed] and put people’s lives at risk.”

“What do you think?” she asked Officer Wilson again. “Just tickets?”

Officer Brown then opened a coin-flip application on her phone, FOX News reported.

“A [arrest] head, R [release] tail,” Officer Wilson said.

“Okay,” Officer Brown replied.

“This is tails, right?” Officer Wilson asked her.

“Yeah,” Officer Brown confirmed. “So, release?”

“Twenty-three,” Officer Wilson corrected – giving her the radio code for arrest.

Officer Brown returned to Webb’s vehicle to take her into custody.

“Why am I being arrested?” she asked the officer.

“Because, ma’am, you were driving entirely too fast for conditions,” Officer Brown explained. “You put a lot of people’s lives in jeopardy, okay?”

Webb was charged with reckless driving, speeding, and driving too fast for conditions, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported.

Although she was lawfully arrested, Webb was unaware that a coin-toss app was used to help determine whether she would be cited and released or taken into custody until she was notified of the bodycam footage by WXIA.

Roswell Police Chief Rusty Grant said he was unaware of the circumstances of Webb’s arrest until just prior to July 4, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported.

He said he immediately placed Officer Brown and Officer Wilson on paid administrative leave and launched an internal investigation into the incident.

“This behavior is not indicative of the hard-working officers of the Roswell Police Department,” Chief Grant told The Atlanta Journal-Constitution on Friday. “I have much higher expectations of our police officers, and I am appalled that any law enforcement officer would trivialize the decision-making process of something as important as the arrest of a person.”

“I couldn’t believe what I was seeing,” the chief told NBC News. “This isn’t a police procedure, to bring a coin flip…that’s not part of that decision making to decide to take someone’s freedom.”

On July 9, the charges against Webb were dismissed, WXIA reported.

“I think they should be fired,” Webb told FOX News. “I don’t think at all that they should be getting a paid vacation.”

You can watch bodycam footage of the traffic stop in the video below:

Comments (13)
No. 1-13
  1. Why were the charges dismissed? It was a legitimate arrest regardless of the coin toss.
  2. Almost all police officers have at one time or another made a mental "coin toss" decision. Even the Chief, assuming he actually made an arrest before being promoted.
  3. This woman now wants the officers fired!? For what? She may not like how they came to the conclusion to arrest her, but the phucking charges were good.
  4. And yet another Chief forgetting where he came from. Verbal counselling is all that is needed, certainly not a suspension and IA.
  5. I am sooooooooooooo happy to be out of law enforcement. Departments in this country are being run by Chiefs who are scared to stand up to public pressure.

I know, right!

Burgers Allday
Burgers Allday

I basically agree with LEO0301 on this one.

Burgers Allday
Burgers Allday

What makes this situation interesting is that it seems like a borderline case where arresting would be a reasonable, justifiable decision and also not arresting would be a reasonable, justifiable decision. It is not like they were going to let her go without a reckless driving citation. They were flipping a coin between two reasonable alternatives, which looks bad , but I don't think it is that bad in a substantive sense.


I think she should of gotten tickets, I see people getting released when they find majuana in a car!! She needed to get to work no excuse for her speeding and the coin toss was not a big deal!!!


Like who hasn't done that? I mean... the woman had a chance. Karma was just not with her that day...


LOL cop math. "I had to got 90 just to catch her therefore she must have been doing 80-85". What a joke.

Burgers Allday
Burgers Allday

I also agree with supadupa man


I'm sure that those two Officers are very capable and duty minded, but they should never have done that while the bodycam was running, it was bad judgement. That must've slipped their minds. It was stupid and callous.


Stupid woman needed to go to jail, coin toss or not. The Chief needs to grow a set and quit making such a drama out of it.


This is embarrassing to anyone that served in Law Enforcement. Very unprofessional.. this department should review their training and policies concerning traffic enforcement and common sense decision making.


Give it a rest Chief. Guess you forgot what being a road dog is all about. So they flipped a coin! The driver broke the law, then gets off because a news agency made a flap about it. Being politically correct isn't always right. You should back your officers and tell the news to go pound sand. And Cidcsp--- you must wear a white shirt, asshole.