Dead Drug Dealer's Family Demands $5M After They Accepted Settlement Years Ago

The family of Anthony Lamar Smith is demanding $5 million even though they already got paid for the shooting death.

By Holly Matkin, Christopher Berg

St. Louis, MO A suspect's family filed new paperwork Aug. 19 demanding $5 million for a previously settled wrongful death lawsuit.

The family justified their decision by claiming officials were involved in a "cover-up," according to KMOV.

St. Louis Police Department (SLPD) Officer Jason Stockley fatally shot drug-dealer Anthony Lamar Smith on Dec. 20, 2011, after Smith rammed his vehicle into Officer Stockleys patrol car, forcing the vehicle to collide with another car, the Belleville News-Democrat reported.

Before Smith and his accomplice fled the scene, officers noticed a gun on the passenger seat of the suspects vehicle. Smith then led police on a three minute high-speed pursuit on wet roadways, and at times drove into oncoming traffic.

Smith ultimately stopped his vehicle, and officers rushed towards him, and reached inside his vehicle.

During the struggle that ensued, Officer Stockley fired his duty weapon five times, killing Smith.

Investigators later recovered a handgun and a bag of heroin from inside Smiths vehicle.

Federal and state prosecutors initially declined to charge Officer Stockley in relation to the shooting, the St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported.

Attorney Albert Watkins filed a civil lawsuit against SLPD on behalf of Smiths family, which settled for $900,000 in 2013.

Following the settlement, Officer Stockley was indicted for first-degree murder, after now-former Circuit Attorney Jennifer Joyce claimed to have discovered new evidence in the case.

Joyce alleged that Officer Stockley had planted the gun found inside Smiths vehicle, because the officers DNA was found on the weapon.

The indictment also relied heavily on the testimony of SLPD internal affairs investigator Kirk Deeken.

Deeken repeatedly told grand jurors that Officer Stockley executed Smith by firing a fifth shot at close range about 22 seconds after he had fired four other shots, the St. Louis Post-Dispatchreported.

The prosecutors used Deekens theory during the murder trial, and called Officer Stockleys fifth bullet a kill shot. The prosecutors described how a puff of gun smoke that was seen on the police SUVs dash camera was proof of that fifth kill shot.

But a cellphone video clip taken by a nearby business owner showed Officer Elijah Simpson was there when the fifth shot was allegedly fired. Officer Simpson told the grand jury and at trial that he didnt see or hear any additional shots. In all, there was no evidence of a "kill shot" besides the "smoke."

At trial, Judge Wilson concluded that the puff of smoke was exhaled breath in cold air.

Deeken also testified that only Officer Stockleys DNA was found on a silver .38 caliber Taurus revolver that Deeken said he found inside Smiths car.

Deeken told the grand jury that a DNA expert told him that Officer Stockleys DNA on the gun came from his blood, but Officer Stockley had no open wounds after the shooting. This suggested the blood had to have been left on weapon the before the shooting, which would be evidence that the gun was planted.

During Deekens deposition in May, he said he couldnt remember why he told the grand jury that Officer Stockleys blood was on the gun.

At trial, the same DNA expert said he didnt tell Deeken that Officer Stockleys blood was on the gun. The DNA expert said that the citys crime lab could only confirm the presence of DNA, but not its biological source. Officer Stockley had recovered the gun from Smith's vehicle and unloaded it, and his DNA could have been easily transferred while touching it.

Deeken told the grand jury that Stockley violated department policy by handling the gun. In his deposition, Deeken admitted that at the time of the shooting in 2011, the police department had no policy forbidding officers from handling weapons used against them.

Deeken testified in a sworn deposition in May that he knew of no new evidence given to Joyce, who has since retired. Joyce claimed that the Internal Affairs Division presented her with new evidence which allowed her to file the charges after her own office and federal prosecutors had previously declined to charge them.

The St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported that Joyce never identified the new evidence. And Joyces successor Kim Gardner said she could not say what it was.

Officer Stockleys attorney, Neil Bruntrager, said that Deekens testimony was crucial.

Without Deekens testimony, I believe they never would have got an indictment, Bruntrager said. The indictment gave the case, integrity that it didnt deserve. [Prosecutors] gave people an expectation that there was something here when, in fact, there wasnt.

You have in the prosecutor a position of trust when you have a grand jury, Bruntrager said. And when you put a witness like Deeken on, you are saying to them, This is believable, and they take your lead and they ultimately got an indictment, and I think thats a violation of the public trust.

Judge Timothy Wilson acquitted Officer Stockley on Sep. 15, 2017.

Watkins said that, during the civil lawsuit, he was never made aware that only Officer Stockleys DNA had been found on the weapon recovered from Smiths vehicle, the St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported.

He argued that the DNA information could have impacted the settlement figure, and filed motions to reopen the lawsuit.

At the request of Attorney General Josh Hawley, former federal prosecutor Hal Goldsmith launched an investigation into the case, and determined that the DNA evidence had not been turned over to Watkins, despite court mandates.

Judge Jean Hamilton considered Goldsmiths findings when she made her decision to reopen the civil lawsuit, Watkins said.

The court has wide discretion here, Watkins added in March. If we have contempt found by the court, it can say it would be worth $1 million more. Im looking for as much money as humanly possible.

The family has since amended that figure to be $5 million.

Comments (26)
No. 1-21
LEO0301
LEO0301

The ghetto lottery - The gift that keeps on giving.

Just-My-Thoughts
Just-My-Thoughts

Amazing how fast the family went through $900k.

hampshire
hampshire

Some slick attorney got to them. They settled so must have signed off ?

diverrick
diverrick

Yup, ghetto lottery all the way. Sad state of affairs.. the fact that he was a drug dealer and carrying, seems to have no value. And they wonder why they always get blaimed for shit. You do the crime, you do the time. It is simple. Be law abiding and you'll be just fine.

ReserveDepty3431
ReserveDepty3431

My baby dindu nuffin!

TCSO7801
TCSO7801

Joyce and Deekins.... what incompetence. Personal grudge against officer by Deekins? Thank goodness Joyce is "former"..... did she go to work in Baltimore...

angeleyes
angeleyes

just take all the money the city has and dole it out equally between all the thugs and their families who were "murdered" by LEOs and be done with it. bankrupt the city, and take all our taxes toward the poor innocent thugs who never pay taxes and live off welfare and drugs. Why can't the families only get what the thugs would earn in their short lives. I call it thug lottery and it seems to be tilted toward the thugs. do juries not understand, they are so stupid, that the money they give comes out of their taxes.

61mouse
61mouse

Guess they are trying to get off welfare .

61mouse
61mouse

Lawyers a a d some judges are WORDT then the thugs, and thugs families

Lilnatvsavg
Lilnatvsavg

They dont deserve a damn thing! They probably got kicked off welfare so they want more money. Thing is theyll rip thru that as well w/in a few yrs & want more. If there was no new evidence shown & DNA WAS NOT actually there they should be made to pay the first payout back! Make them get a job!

Stanracer
Stanracer

Another family trying to get rich off their drug dealing, scumbag son. They already got paid. This is BS.!👎😣

GForce48
GForce48

Great to see "the community" supporting a drug dealer! This is the shit that has police officers across the country patrolling with blinders on. Thanks 0bama!

robocop95
robocop95

Unbelievable. This country is upside down.

Cstuartsr
Cstuartsr

Its amazing to me that the St Louis area has turned out to be such Sh&@Hole part of the country. Then you have Peosecutors that embedded with drug dealers and thugs that are all looking to hang Law Enforcement Officers for anything. Corruption in MO is unbelievable among prosecutors and thugs!!

THEDUKE
THEDUKE

Hello Cstuartsr - "Its amazing to me that the St Louis area has turned out to be such Sh&@Hole part of the country."

C- St Louis is the tip of a much larger iceberg . You can see the same psychotic behaviors in Chicago, Detroit, Philadelphia, Camden, Newark, Baltimore, DC, Atlanta, Bronx , Oakton, LA, etc,etc,etc.........or in other similar locations where there is a large representation of this same dysfunctional minority community. Readers may wrongly assume its only in their own area because the local news they receive just covers their own location. Consider Chicago-Although the crime,shootings ,perpetrators and victims continue on a daily basis...It now happens so often that most readers only see the most heinous examples reported ,as journalists cannot provide coverage for each example which occurs. Though Chicago may be the current "front runner" it is no where near the only city as these same actors play out the same sick performances whether Chicago, St.Louis or similar.

chiefd
chiefd

So an officer kills a heroin dealer, but he was a good boy who was turning his life around. Yeah, right. I hope the family of this POS gets nothing, and SLPD counter sues and gets the original 900,000 back. That would be justice.

TarnishedCopper
TarnishedCopper

Wow, what a case of "He Said: She Said: Or MABE THEY DIDN't SAY!!" If it walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, most likely it is!! Talk about a railroad Choo Choo job!

JBo
JBo

Ghetto Lottery...Round 2.

Back The Blue
Back The Blue

Double Jeopardy should apply here also. Bet the original 900,000 went up in smoke per these good, law-abiding citizens. (Cough) Sorry!

pbm4jc
pbm4jc

hood rats are starving

Richard Kurtz
Richard Kurtz

I suppose they blew the rest of the money in short order so now they "need" more. They shouldn't have gotten a dime to begin with.